Colorado Supreme Court Invalidates Nursing Home Arbitration Agreements
Citing that the power to make medical decision is different from the ability to settle disputes via private system, the Colorado Supreme Court invalidated nursing home arbitration agreements signed by healthcare proxies. The decision was handed down in Lujan v. Life Care Centers of America.
In this case, Estella Lujan was admitted to a Life Care Center in Colorado after her son signed admission paperwork and the arbitration agreement. Three days later, Ms. Lujan died. Her family filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the facility alleging that her death was due to negligence. Life Care Center filed a motion to dismiss stating that the lawsuit should be dismissed due to the signed arbitration agreement.
Since the Colorado Supreme Court ruled against nursing home arbitration agreements signed by healthcare proxies, the Lujan case will continue its procession through the court process and will eventually proceed to trial.

